My Rating: ⭐⭐⭐
Neal Schusterman’s All Better Now is a speculative fiction novel that dives headfirst into one of humanity’s greatest philosophical debates: would we be better off without negative emotions? Set against the backdrop of a pandemic eerily reminiscent of recent history, this book offers an insightful yet complex exploration of happiness, identity, and what it truly means to be human.
If you’re curious whether this thought-provoking read is for you, here’s a breakdown of the book’s strengths, weaknesses, and why it might be perfect for your next book club pick.
The Premise
In Schusterman’s imagined world, the Crown Royale virus is sweeping the globe. Those who survive its 5% mortality rate emerge with a peculiar “side effect”: they are no longer capable of feeling grief, anger, anxiety, or depression. Instead, they’re left in a state of eternal contentment.
While this might sound like the ultimate gift, the consequences are anything but straightforward. Society is split between those who see the virus as a dangerous erasure of human personality and those who believe it’s a miraculous solution to the pain of existence. This central debate powers much of the book’s tension and makes it a perfect discussion starter for readers who love exploring ethical dilemmas.
What Works
- A Fascinating Concept
The idea of a happiness virus is both unique and thought-provoking, opening the door to countless “What would you do?” moments. It challenges readers to reflect on their own relationship with emotions, pain, and what makes us human. - Insightful Writing
Schusterman has a knack for asking big questions in an accessible way. His exploration of the social and personal impacts of Crown Royale feels eerily realistic, and his observations will leave you pondering long after you’ve closed the book. - Great for Book Clubs
With its morally complex premise, All Better Now is practically made for discussion groups. Whether you’re debating the ethics of spreading the virus or reflecting on how much our emotions shape our identity, there’s no shortage of topics to dive into.
What Doesn’t Work
- Too Many Characters
The story alternates between three main POVs—Morgan, Mariel, and Rón—but also includes a large cast of side characters. This abundance of perspectives makes the narrative feel overcrowded and detracts from emotional immersion. - Overly Ambitious Plot
While the premise is intriguing, the execution feels a bit overstuffed. Side-stories and subplots add unnecessary length to a story that could have been more impactful if streamlined. - Close to Home
For readers who are still processing the events of the Covid-19 pandemic, the book’s setting might feel a little too familiar. With mask-wearing, isolation, and debates about public health taking center stage, the parallels might make some readers uncomfortable.
Final Thoughts
All Better Now is a book with a lot to say, but it doesn’t always say it effectively. While the concept is compelling and the writing insightful, the overcrowded narrative and pandemic-heavy themes make it hard to fully lose yourself in the story.
That said, it’s a great pick for readers who enjoy speculative fiction with a philosophical edge or anyone looking for a book that will spark deep conversations.
Would I recommend it? Yes—but primarily to readers who love debating big ideas or are seeking a discussion-worthy book for their club.
3 responses to “Would You Give Up Your Emotions for Eternal Happiness? A Review of All Better Now by Neal Schusterman”
it does sound interesting and highly provocative. Do you think it might have been more effective as a series? Excellent review, Tessa💜
I do like the sound of this as I really enjoy speculative fiction that asks big questions. I’ve added it to my TBR but we’ll see if I actually get around to reading it.
I’ve got an ARC of this one I’m anxious to get to. The long cast list might be an issue for me also.